Shikellamy Middle School Revisted...ICF's Spell Savings

Shikellamy MS 1

Quick overview

  • ICF construction helps reduce gas costs over 65%
  • Performance of ICF's proves their merit
Concrete Producer

Central Builders Supply

General Contractors

eciConstruction

Location

Northumberland, PA

The Situation

In 2016 the Shikellamy School District constructed a new middle school. Shikellamy Middle School combined the former Sunbury and C.W. Rice Middle Schools. The finished three-story building has two wings and houses about 650 students in grades six through eight. It includes two technology education suites, six science labs and 24 classrooms.

The architects for the project, McKissick Associates hoped to design a building that was cost-efficient, durable and economically sustainable. They chose to use Insulated Concrete Forms (ICF’s) to meet their needs.

Mr. Doug Benick has worked for the school district for 29 years including the last six as the School District’s Director of Buildings and Grounds. He shared his thoughts about the construction process and how the school is “performing”.

While we only have one year’s worth of natural gas use to compare costs, we estimate that cost to be approximately $.15 per square foot in the new school versus $.49 per square foot for the older buildings. That is significant.


~ Doug Benick, Director of Buildings and Grounds

The Solution

“When McKissick Associates first brought the idea of using ICF’s to the School Board there were many who were not familiar with them. Carl Kanaskie (McKissick’s project manager) did a great job of explaining what they were, how they perform, and why they would provide the District with a good Return On Investment (ROI). We are pleased with the results that we have seen to date” stated Benick.

“The school is heated with two small condensate boilers. Frankly, there was concern (by District staff) that the units were undersized. It is the efficiency of the ICF walls that allow the system to be downsized. While we only have one year’s worth of natural gas use to compare costs, we estimate that cost to be approximately $.15 per square foot in the new school versus $.49 per square foot for the older buildings. That is significant” he continued.

Lastly, he stated that “Construction took place over two winters which was challenging. Because the forms are insulated, concrete can be placed in them during cold weather which enabled the project to keep moving.”

The District is conducting a feasibility study on the high school to determine future needs (repair versus new construction). Would the District like to incorporate ICF’s in upcoming projects? “They have performed well, and we would support using them again” concluded Benick.

Gallery

Recommended Case Studies

DSCN1322 w1000 h1000
Roller Compacted Concrete (RCC) Provides the Best and Most Cost-Effective Solution for PPL
  • RCC proved to be a substantial savings to PPL.
  • The project also featured full-depth reclamation for the base.
View Case Study
Facade3
Windom Hill Place

Built into a hillside, ICF construction met the challenge of this project site.

View Case Study
Pervious Picnic Area 005
Lebanon County Conservation District Chooses Colored Pervious Concrete

Unique pattern and color make this pervious concrete pad stand out.

View Case Study
DSCN0127
Liberty Property Trust - Lewisberry

The project featured tilt-up concrete construction as well as pervious and roller compacted concrete pavements.

View Case Study
P8110168
Fulton Bank Pervious Concrete Parking Area

Pervious concrete was selected because it offered a life-cycle cost advantage over asphalt.

View Case Study
DSCN1007
Parker Hill Church: A Pervious Concrete Win

Pervious concrete allowed the addition to be built, while maintaining impervious cover limits.

View Case Study
ICF
Concrete Offers Advantages in Green School Building

The building features Insulating Concrete Form (ICF) construction.

View Case Study
2012 06 21 093637 w1000 h1000
Sycamore Street Project Incorporates Roller Compacted Concrete
  • First RCC street project placed in Pennsylvania.
  • RCC proved to be the most cost effective alternative.
View Case Study
2012 10 17 122430 w1000 h1000
Norfolk Southern Selects Roller Compacted Concrete
  • RCC selected to meet the demanding pavement needs for this inter-modal facility.
  • Fast-tracked projects sees 35,000 cubic yards of concrete placed in 22 days.
View Case Study
Product Information Shts
Susquehanna River Lodge - Decorative Concrete in Action
  • These homeowners wanted to build a "sustainable" home. Decorative concrete helpd them achieve their goal.
  • Pennsylvania Aggregates and Concrete Association 2012 Residential Project of the Year.
View Case Study
IMG 9690
Roller Compacted Concrete Answers Baker Hughes’ Needs

RCC placement met pavement load requirements and need for quick construction turn-around.

View Case Study
2013 09 06 06 34 27 w1200 h1200 1
Conewago Constructs Worlds Fifth Largest Tilt-Up Concrete Building
  • 1.7 million square foot tilt-up project also incorporated 45,000 cubic yards of RCC.
  • Challenging soil conditions met through cement stabilization.
View Case Study
Prep Buchart Horn
PennDOT Approves RCC for Peanut Drive (Conewago Twp. PA) Project
  • Project incorporated PennDOT RCC specifications.
  • First municipal RCC project in Pennsylvania to receive Liquid Fuels funding.
View Case Study
Decorative Commercial 5
Market Value - Concrete Critical in Making Grocery More Eco-Friendly
  • Project totaled 3000 cubic yards of concrete.
  • Lighting and maintenance costs reduced by using concrete.
  • Pennsylvania Aggregates and Concrete Association 2014 Decorative Project of the Year - Commercial
View Case Study
Catasagua Concrete Street
Catasauqua Borough Chooses Concrete Solution for Street Project

Concrete was the answer for the severe rutting that the street was experiencing.

View Case Study
Commercial 2 w800 h600
Urban Outfitters Distribution Center Counts on Concrete
  • Pennsylvania Aggregates and Concrete Association 2014 Commercial Project of the Year - Buildings
  • 1,000,000 sft. tilt-up concrete project.
  • Required 40,000 cubic yards of concrete.
View Case Study
Decorative Residential 7 w800 h600 1
Concrete Enhances Outdoor Living Space
  • Homeowners wanted a maintenance-free, natural looking enhancement for their swimming pool.
  • Decorative concrete was chosen to meet their needs.
  • Pennsylvania Aggregates and Concrete Association 2014 Decorative Project of the Year - Residential
View Case Study
IMG 20161012 1021
Township’s Use Of RCC Saves Taxpayer Dollars, Prevents Lengthy Road Closures
  • Township needed a long-lasting solution to improve deteriorated roadway
  • The 200-cubic-yard roadway was completed and opened to traffic in 24 hours
  • RCC delivered taxpayer cost-savings of 65%
View Case Study
20161025 105315
Growing Business Builds Winter-ready Lot
  • Growing manufacturing business turned to RCC for increased efficiency
  • RCC with spray asphalt seal helps melt ice and snow to alleviate winter weather maintenance
  • RCC upgrades 19,000-square-foot gravel lot to provide durability under heavy truck traffic
View Case Study
IMG 0084
Pennsylvania’s First Virtual Pipeline Needs Durable Terminal
  • Pennsylvania’s first virtual pipeline needed a durable terminal
  • Newly paved 29,000 square feet will withstand heavy truck traffic
  • RCC contributed to quick construction timeline
View Case Study
Central Photo 7
Middle School Thrives in New Sustainable, Durable Building
  • Durable design helps manage maintenance costs.
  • ICF construction adds environmental sustainability.
  • Project timeline aided by ICF use.
View Case Study
20171020 132511
AgSalt Processing Recognizes Value of Concrete Strength and Durability
  • Heavy Pavement Loadings Demand Tough Pavement
  • Lighter colored concrete pavement is more reflective and requires fewer lights
View Case Study
TLC 1
The Land Conservancy for Southern Chester County Selects Pervious Concrete
  • The environmentally sensitive area required a pavement solution that fit its natural surroundings
  • Pervious concrete will allow potential stormwater runoff to now percolate through the pavement and into the ground
View Case Study
Merion Station 1
Merion Station Provides "Concrete" Value for Residents
  • Townhouse project constructed with Insulating Concrete Forms
  • Includes concrete street and driveways
View Case Study
20190925 112329
GDS Chooses RCC for New Maintenance Facility
  • Truck traffic at the facility would require a durable pavement, and long service life.
  • The owner was seeking value for their money.
View Case Study
2013 09 06 06 34 27 w1200 h1200
Conewago Constructs Worlds Fifth Largest Tilt-up Concrete Building
  • 1.7 million square foot tilt-up project also incorporated 45,000 cubic yards of RCC.
  • Challenging soil conditions met through cement stabilization.
View Case Study
Meshoppen RCC 2
RCC Meets Meshoppen Stone’s Pavement Needs
  • With as many as 250 trucks per day using the facility, a durable pavement was a priority
  • A quick project turnaround allowed the company to minimize any downtime at the facility
View Case Study
NESL 2
Roller Compacted Concrete Continues to Meet Customer Needs
  • Heavy truck traffic required strong, durable paving solution
  • Company’s successful history sing Roller Compacted Concrete (RCC) drove decision to utilize RCC for the project
View Case Study
20210115 095046
ICFs - Keeping This Mixed-Use Development Green
  • Insulated Concrete Forms (ICFs) provide an energy efficient alternative to conventional building materials
  • Lumber price volatility is a challenge to today's builder
View Case Study
20220815 144655
ICF Construction Proves to be the Solution for York Building Products Facility
  • ICF's were chosen over stick framing, modular, and pole building construction options
  • Concrete roof will serve as floor system for vertical expansion of building
View Case Study
8 Stronwall Frame
Strong Walls Make a Unique Solution for Penn State Facility

Project is one of only eight strong walls in the US, and the only one poured monolithically

View Case Study
Adobe Stock 465164163

PACA's Online e-Learning Center

The program is delivered in one (1) module and it should take approximately 30 minutes to complete.  You will receive a certificate of completion once you pass the quiz. The bookmarking feature will allow you to leave the course and resume where you left off when you return.

The Pennsylvania Aggregates and Concrete Association (PACA) is the industry’s unified voice, representing more than 200 member companies across the state.